top of page

Do Bad Bosses Know They're Bad? Michael Walsh on Growing Managers

Jul 27, 2025
5 min read

Updated: Oct 29

Middle management may be the toughest job in any company. Michael Walsh, in part twelve of the Freedom by Design series, makes the case for why. Most managers got the role because they were very good at doing the work. Nobody trained them to support someone else in doing it. And those are different skills. In a service business, where the expertise of your people is the thing you deliver, that gap shows up everywhere. Michael runs an exercise in his management workshops. Name your best boss, then your worst, and say what made them that way. The two lists mirror each other. Then many managers notice they do things on the worst boss list. Most bad bosses, Michael says, don't know they're bad. If you own a business and promote your best people into management, this is about you.

Inspired by Paper Napkin Wisdom Episode 274 with Michael Walsh pt 12.

Why your best performer may not be your best manager

The logic of promotion makes sense on the surface. You trust this person to get the job done. So they seem like the one you would trust most to get results through the team. Michael calls that trust misplaced, and his reason is simple. The skills it takes to deliver a result are very different from the skills it takes to support somebody else to generate the result.

The manager sits in the middle of everything. Multiple bosses above, multiple people below, and an expectation to just handle it. Most were never trained for it. Michael points to Wayne Gretzky as the example. One of the best hockey players of all time, he had an intuitive skill that didn't translate into coaching. Larry Robinson and Jacques Lemaire, two defensemen from the Montreal Canadiens, went on to coach together with the New Jersey Devils. Michael's view is that they were brilliant coaches because they had conscious thought of what they were doing. Gretzky knew it for himself. He didn't know how to teach it.

Good with people is not the same as knowing how to manage. Being great at the work is not the same either.

What makes the best boss and the worst boss

Michael starts with a definition he credits to Marcus Buckingham, who was one of the lead people at Gallup. Management is taking the talents of people and turning them into performance.

Then the workshop. When managers describe their best boss, the lists come back remarkably similar from group to group. Clear, simple communication. Consistent and respectful. Encouraging of my ideas. Trusted me and gave me independence. Calm, patient, protective of the team. Walked the talk. Pushed people out of their comfort zone. Gave feedback, good and bad. Never micromanaged.

The worst boss list reads like the reverse. Condescending. Took credit for my work. Micromanaging things that were inconsequential. Liked being a boss more than getting the job done. Gave no context for tasks. Indecisive, unpredictable, secretive, visibly stressed all the time. Good results were theirs, and anything wrong was your fault.

I notice how many of these are point and counterpoint. And clear communication shows up near the top of the best boss list, with transparency close behind. Best bosses are not necessarily less demanding. They know what winning looks like, and they can show you how to get there.

Do bad bosses know they're bad?

Mostly, no. Michael has trained groups of managers ranging from ten to around seventy at a time. When they read back what they themselves had written about good and bad bosses, about half of them realize they do some of the things on the bad boss list. It can feel like a small crisis. In a group of more than twenty, he says, at least one person usually wants to quit management.

The Gallup research he cites points the same way. Across more than 2 million employees and 150,000 managers, about 10% of managers were great managers. Yet when surveyed, 71% of managers placed themselves in the top 20%. People assume that because they care, understand the job and get projects across the line, they must be good at managing.

Michael's response to the managers who panic is reassuring. All is not lost. These are skills, and people can learn them.

How influence works when position power stops working

Michael contrasts two models. The 20th century business ran like a well-oiled machine, and each person was a part of it. The 21st century business works more like an intelligent ecosystem. In management, the difference comes down to prescribed power against the power of influence.

Prescribed power comes from the position. People comply while you're watching and stop when you leave. Influence is earned through credibility. People trust you because you've done it, and because you treat them like a human being. Michael's point is that people need to feel understood by you before they care what you know. When that's missing, you might get a good soldier. But in his words, "you don't have my brain at the table."

This matters more in a service business. In a product business, inputs and outcomes can be broken down into fixed tasks. In a service business you need people thinking. My view is that it starts with connection. You can't challenge anyone you aren't connected to, and you connect by being interested in them.

What a manager's job really is

Michael's test is direct. If somebody isn't interested in the growth of their people, keep them away from management. There's no formula for this. What works for one person won't work for the next, the same way two children in one family need different things.

He also names a structural mistake owners make as they grow. If management pays the most, everyone steers toward it, including people who would be far more valuable as specialists. Michael's fix is to treat specialist and manager as two separate career paths, each rewarding in its own right.

And the math of management favors the manager who grows people. If you have six people and do your job halfway decent, the six will outperform the one. Even someone who can do the work of two or three people can't do the work of six.

I'd add a point about how owners measure managers. Most of the metrics are about the project. Very few are about the people.

How to apply this in your business this week

Run Michael's exercise with your own managers. Ask each of them to write down the initials of their best boss and what made that person the best. Then the worst boss, and what made them the worst. Put the lists side by side and talk them through.

Then try a few honest checks of your own:

  • Look at who you promoted most recently. Were they chosen for doing the job, or for growing people?

  • Ask whether your specialists can earn as much as your managers. If not, you may be pushing the wrong people into management.

  • Find one people-related measure for each manager, next to the project measures you already track.

  • Notice where a manager is relying on position rather than earned credibility.

The managers who flinch at the worst boss list are not the problem. They're the ones ready to learn.

Michael Walsh and I co-founded Growth & Impact Partners, which delivers the Complete Growth Program and the Freedom Framework developed by Walsh Business Growth Institute. To see where your own business is stuck, take the Growth Pattern Diagnostic.

Related Insights

Wisdom Weekly. Get Wisdom Weekly, a short Sunday letter on leading what you have built. Subscribe to Wisdom Weekly

This conversation is part of the Managing a Team Growth Hub, number 3 in its top 10. See every Growth Hub.

🎙️ Listen to Episode 274 of Paper Napkin Wisdom

Learn more:

  • White LinkedIn Icon
  • Youtube
  • White Instagram Icon
  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Twitter Icon
  • TikTok

©2011-2026 by Govindh Jayaraman

Can we help you win?

bottom of page