What Is Masculine Containment? Alex Charfen on Holding Your Center When It Matters Most
Updated: Oct 29
Alex Charfen has built multiple fast-growing companies and was one of the most sought-after CEO coaches around. A few years ago his wife Cadey told him, "I don't feel heard, I don't feel seen, and I don't feel safe", and that something needed to change. He thought they were doing fine. Like many driven men, his instinct was to fix it. What actually worked was the opposite. He sat down with her every day, held his center, and let her say whatever she needed to say. Out of that came what he calls masculine containment. It means containing yourself first, containing your reactions when someone you love is emotional, and actively creating space for them to be heard. In our conversation, Alex, a close friend of mine for more than a decade, explains what it is, why fixing often makes things worse, and what changed for him and the men he now works with.
Inspired by Paper Napkin Wisdom Episode 339 with Alex Charfen.
What happens when the person you love says she doesn't feel safe
Alex and Cadey have been together 22 years and married for 20. When she told him she didn't feel heard, seen or safe, he did what most capable men would do. He asked what she needed and how to fix it.
She didn't know. She only knew how she felt.
So he went all in. He was running a company called Simple Operations and cut his time there to about twelve hours a week. The rest went into books, videos, articles and coaching. Things got better. He still could not find the root cause.
The turning point came through a series of ceremonies the couple took part in. The message he received was that he needed to sit down with Cadey every day, hold his center, and let her say whatever she needed to say. He found that terrifying. He did it anyway. On December 26th, 2023, he set up a space in their bedroom, and they began sitting together every day.
Why defending yourself feels right and makes things worse
Those early conversations were the hardest thing Alex had ever done. Cadey told him, in detail, about moments where he had made her feel unseen and unsafe. Every part of him wanted to say that's not what I meant.
He didn't. He slowed down and stayed in the moment. Then he realized that what she was telling him was her truth. Any move to correct her, or explain what he had intended, was invalidating her. And he had done exactly that, over and over, in their marriage.
He describes a pattern he sees in many couples. A trigger, then escalation, then damage, then withdrawal, then repair. For men, he says, that cycle can feel productive. Identify the conflict, neutralize it, move on. In his experience, women often do not return to baseline that fast, and repair can mean only that the pain has stopped for now.
His advice to men who feel they are walking on eggshells is direct. He tells them that "anytime you're bringing too much energy to the situation to solve a problem, you actually become the problem."
The three kinds of masculine containment
Alex defines masculine containment in three ways.
Containing yourself. Most men, he says, are uncontained. His father had serious road rage, and once rammed another car in a parking lot in Las Vegas while Alex watched at thirteen. Alex picked up the same pattern. Now, when someone cuts him off, he breathes and processes the anger instead of letting it leak out as aggression. Containment can be practiced and learned.
Reactive containment. When Cadey was upset, Alex used to do one of four things. He would tell her she shouldn't feel that way. He would build a process so it never happened again, which turned her into a project. Sometimes he withdrew to give her space. Or he matched her emotion, and often exceeded it. All four left her feeling invalidated.
Recently their daughter moved out, and he found Cadey crying on the edge of the bed. The old Alex would have walked out. This time he sat down next to her and said, I've got you. Nothing about the situation changed. The feelings were processed, and she felt better.
Active containment. This is deliberately calling your partner in. Sit down, ask what is happening for them, and listen. Then ask whether there is anything else they need to say, and whether there is anything you need to do.
What changed when other men tried it
Alex started sharing these ideas on social media. Three men reached out within about an hour of each other, so he put them on one call and worked with them for ten weeks. Around the third or fourth week, he asked them to call their partners into active containment.
The results were mixed and real. One marriage is still challenged, though that man is grounded and has hope. For the newlywed, the rupture cleared, and after a few sessions his wife asked how she could support him. The third man had been in near-constant rupture. Within weeks, intimacy returned, and later he shared that his wife was pregnant. When he promised her it would be different this time, she said it already was.
Alex's next group, through the Brotherhood Society, grew to more than a hundred men. He holds an undying belief that any man can do this with the right tools, process and understanding. He also shares a message from one of his ceremonies that many men need to hear, that "you already are the person you're trying to become."
Why containment matters for how you lead
Alex is blunt about leadership in the world today. He sees a lot of uncontained men shooting from the hip and causing damage. A contained man becomes a safe place, and in Alex's experience, that is magnetic.
He practices it in public too. A commenter named Kevin spent weeks pushing back on his posts with beliefs Alex considered toxic. Alex answered him directly, with boundaries, and kept his energy in check. If he felt activated while writing a reply, he would stop, breathe or go for a walk, then come back. Over a few weeks Kevin shifted. He is now part of the group.
This connects to my own work on calm as a leadership asset. Calm is the ability to hold complexity and let chaos happen in your presence, then meet it with curiosity. Alex and I also leaned on each other every week through a dark season after a major rupture in my business.
Alex puts the goal simply. As men, we need to become the man that walks into the storm and calms it.
How to apply this in your business and your home this week
Start with yourself, then move outward:
Notice one moment this week where you feel a surge of anger, like being cut off in traffic. Breathe through it and let it settle before you act.
The next time someone close to you is upset, stay. Sit down and say I've got you. Resist the urge to correct, fix, withdraw or match their energy.
Ask, is there anything else you need to say? Keep asking until the answer is no.
Set up one active containment conversation. Choose a time, open the space, listen, then close it.
Before you reply to a hard message at work or online, check your body. If you feel activated, step away first.
Here is the thought I would leave you with. Masculine containment doesn't ask you to control anyone else. It asks you to lead yourself and hold your own center, so safety, truth and connection can exist in the same place.
Related Insights
If you want peers who will help you hold your center as you change how you lead, at work and at home, this is where that work happens. Build the Field
Wisdom Weekly. Get Wisdom Weekly, a short Sunday letter on leading what you have built. Subscribe to Wisdom Weekly
This conversation is part of the Calm Under Pressure Growth Hub, number 1 in its top 10. See every Growth Hub.
🎙️ Listen to Episode 339 of Paper Napkin Wisdom
▶ Spotify
▶ YouTube
