When the Story That Built Your Company Starts Running It
Updated: Oct 29
There is a strange moment that arrives after you have built something that works. The story you carry about yourself has receipts. It built the company, earned the trust, survived the hard years. And because it worked, it is remarkably hard to question. Anna Rosa Parker, founder of EVOKE, writer, narrative strategist and educator, names the mechanism: stories create identity, and identity makes the choices and decisions we take every day. So an unexamined story keeps producing decisions long after the conditions that wrote it changed. The answer is not to erase it. Parker is clear that starting a new chapter does not mean the old chapter was wrong. What she asks is narrower and harder. Does the old story still get authority over the next one? That is the question this episode leaves with anyone who has already built something real.
Inspired by Paper Napkin Wisdom Episode 399 with Anna Rosa Parker.
Stories Create Identity, and Identity Makes the Decisions
Parker describes the sequence as a chain. You examine the story, the story creates the identity, and the identity makes the choices. "So that equal sign is where you are right now."
She is careful to say these stories do not have to be dramatic. Her own examples are small: being clumsy, being unable to sing, always running late. She calls them an engine that runs underneath a life, and she notices herself catching them constantly. "I catch and kill stories all the time, like internally."
For someone leading an established business, notice what that means in practice. A founder can still be leading from a story written when the company was much smaller. Someone can still be proving something to a person who no longer has a seat at the table. Parker also describes the opposite failure, taking on a story that sits a little above where you actually are. Then you don't really fit that identity, and other people register it as something being off even when they can't name it.
The old story may not be wrong. It may simply be finished. Because the conditions that made it true are gone, and nobody told the engine.
Why the Mask Is Hard to Put Down
In the conversation I named the thing a lot of leaders hit as they grow. There comes a point where the old mask has to come down. That mask has receipts. It got results. The mask knew how to walk into the room and make everybody laugh about the hors d'oeuvres. Then it stopped fitting.
Parker answered with something personal. She had been extremely fit for years, and never happy with her body even then. Later, after hormonal changes and a few pounds, she found current photographs unflattering and did not want to use them. A few times. Then she used them anyway.
"This is where we are now. This is what my body looks like right now. And it's okay. I'm still fit, I'm still strong."
What she describes next is the part worth sitting with. "There is a certain freedom in that." Not the freedom you announce, she says, but the kind you reach when you actually mean that it no longer takes up space. Every time you let go of something like that, something opens up and you have more room in your life.
For a proven entrepreneur, the mask is rarely a photograph. It is the decisive founder. The relentless operator. The one with every answer, who can always carry one more thing. That identity works. People around you may even prefer it, because they know what to expect from it. The harder question is whether it still fits your face.
Belief Before Evidence: Acting Before the Proof Arrives
I talk often about belief before evidence. Most people want to see it first. But who you're becoming isn't here yet, so there is nothing to look at.
Parker lives this at an ordinary, daily scale. She says she does something new most days that she has no proof of. "I don't have the receipt, you know, I'm gonna do it." She does not dress up the cost either. A lot of the time it fails, and that is okay. Working for yourself, she says, comes with some crying, some exhaustion, a fair amount of guessing, and stretches where you are not confident in what you're building.
Her framing of why this matters is about the unknown. If you already know how it ends and what you're going to say, she says, that is predictable to you, and you stay stuck in the same story. Walking into something when you do not yet know how it goes is what she calls trusting yourself in the unknown. That, she says, is where things evolve and where you start to elevate your identity.
Her own path makes the point for her. Competitive aerobics in Iceland. Parents who said there are free schools here, figure the rest out yourself. Years to find the money, then drama at the University of Washington, acting, writing plays, a solo show. Acting stopped fitting, so she talked her way into a job at Nordstrom that she calls a grad school in marketing. New York, agencies, in-house work. Losing the job in the pandemic, continuing with clients, and out of that time building EVOKE Your Story.
Looking backward, the pieces connect. Living forward, they did not. She says she wanted to figure out how we connect the dots going forward, and what she landed on was this: if you are aware of the stories you are currently living and portraying, maybe you can.
The Antagonist That Returns You to the Same Loop
Parker's most useful warning is about what happens after the new direction starts.
"We're always so excited when we start something. It's like with all the adrenaline and everything, we see it so beautifully, and then the antagonist comes in." She is specific about where the antagonist lives. "That is always something internal that we stop ourselves from doing something. We just sabotage it in a certain way."
If there is no skill for getting past it, the loop closes. "Then we're gonna repeat the same loop." And she names what that costs. Running the same story keeps you in the same loop, and life starts to repeat itself.
I raised the version of this I hear constantly from owners. Just before the step, the plan isn't ready. One more thing. One more rework of the script. Parker's read on that came with a hedge she put on it herself. She is not a therapist, she said, but to her, not being ready to share equals low self worth. If you have elevated your self worth, you know you're worthy of sharing it, warts and all.
The practical move is backward-looking. Think about the last two or three times you tried to make this same change. Find the moment the old pattern came back. That moment will tell you more than another plan will.
Personal Brand Built From Who You Are Now
Parker teaches personal branding at organizations and universities, and she sees the same mistake repeatedly. "People believe they have to become someone else to be seen." They open an account, reach for what they saw working somewhere else, and share something that is not theirs. Her read: "they start to grab all this external stuff before they even start to investigate who they are now today."
Her method runs the other way, and it is small on purpose.
Pick one trait, passion or skill you want to share. "Don't share all of it. It's complicated. Just pick one."
Add one personality aspect. Put those together. That's your story.
Name your values. Parker calls values the GPS, the navigating system, because they decide what you stand for and what you don't stand for.
Then decide what it looks like. Your colors, your words. Her warning is against grabbing the latest trendy font on Canva because it is there.
"We cannot express something that isn't ours."
She is also honest that authenticity is a word thrown around casually, and she gave it a hard definition: living in your truth. It matters to her for a reason she shared with some emotion. Her biological father, who passed a couple of years ago and with whom she had a strenuous relationship, would show up and pretend to be someone he wasn't. "I wanted people to experience who I was, not who they wanted me to be."
Her test for it is a room. "You're authentic when you can walk into a room and you decide you're not gonna take anything." You give, you observe, and you need nothing from anybody. What makes it hard is need. "We don't need the proof of the people. We don't need to connect with them because we want to make a business deal with them." When someone is pushing their giving at you, Parker says that is need wearing a nicer coat. The validation, the recognition. "It's good to notice that before going in."
Her alternative is almost embarrassingly simple. Notice something and say it. "I love that color on you." Or make fun of the hors d'oeuvres if that's who you are. "You walk away from the event much more fulfilled because you were in your truth and you spoke from that and people saw you."
What to Do With This in Your Business This Week
Four moves, all small enough to finish inside a week.
Name the story inside one hard decision. Pick a decision that feels unusually difficult right now. Before you solve it, write down the story about yourself you are bringing into it. Then ask whether that story belongs to the person making this decision today, or to the person who made a similar one years ago.
Keep what the old identity gave you. Take an earlier identity you are reluctant to release. Don't argue about whether it was right. Ask what it gave you that still belongs in the next chapter. Parker's acting training now shows up in her coaching, so the chapters became connected rather than competing.
Act once before the proof arrives. Find the one action you keep postponing until you feel more certain. Decide what a reasonable first step looks like if proof were not a prerequisite, then take that step this week. Parker does this daily and says a lot of it fails, which she treats as part of the territory.
Audit one public thing. Look at how you present yourself now: the bio, the photograph, the way you describe the company. Find one element that feels inherited, copied or outdated. Replace it with something that is accurate to who you are today.
Then carry the question I ended the episode with. What story about who you used to be are you still allowing to make decisions for who you're becoming? Sit with that one. Maybe even write it on a napkin.
The Napkin Moment
If Anna Rosa Parker had to write this on a napkin, she already did:
“Don’t let an old STORY decide who you’re becoming.”
It is worth noticing that the napkin does not tell us to erase the old story.
It asks us to stop giving it authority over the next one.
For the entrepreneur who has already built something real, that may be the harder challenge. The old identity is not necessarily broken. It may still work remarkably well. The question Episode 399 leaves behind is more uncomfortable and more useful:
Is the story that got you here still allowed to decide who you become next?
Related Insights
If the identity that built your company is the one you keep leading from, this is the kind of work that gets examined with other founders who can see what you can't. Build the Field
Wisdom Weekly. Get Wisdom Weekly, a short Sunday letter on leading what you have built. Subscribe to Wisdom Weekly
This conversation is part of the Exits, Freedom and the Second Stage Growth Hub. See every Growth Hub.
🎙️ Listen to Episode 399 of Paper Napkin Wisdom
▶ Spotify
▶ YouTube




cps test, check your speed.
Snow Rider 3D is an endless downhill runner built around speed, steering, and reflexes. Instead of moving through traditional stages, you continuously race down a snowy mountain and attempt to cover the greatest distance possible.