How to Build a Culture of Accountability: John Bly on Leading a Firm
Updated: Oct 29
John Bly is a CPA who has grown his firm through eight acquisitions and two mergers in about nine years. His napkin says accountability is not a four-letter word, so stop treating it like one. Employees, coaches and owners often hear the word as a threat. You must be in trouble. John sees it the opposite way. Accountability drives performance, and it shows you care about people. For a founder, the problem usually starts at the top. If the leader is not willing to be held accountable, the team has no reason to accept it either. When there is no culture of accountability, results drift. John's firm treats it as a shared commitment, with a clear weekly rhythm and coaches whose job is to help. He credits that culture with the firm being named one of the best places to work in Charlotte.
Inspired by Paper Napkin Wisdom Episode 24 with John Bly.
Why accountability feels like a dirty word to your team
John only noticed how negative the word was for others in the last year or so before we spoke. For him it had always been positive. He traces it to his parents, who set goals, wrote checklists and delivered on what they said they would do.
His test is simple. If you say you will be there at three and you show up at four, you have not been accountable to that person. It applies to friends, colleagues and vendors alike.
Many people, though, hear accountability as performance management, or as a boss looking for a reason to be mad. John says the leader has to message it differently. This is about the whole organization getting better, and about people performing better and feeling better at work.
I described it as a bar to reach for, not a stick to beat people with. John agreed, and added that he wants to be the one pushing you over the top of that bar.
Who holds the CEO accountable?
John believes accountability starts at the top. If you are not willing to be held accountable, why would you be able to hold anybody else accountable?
He gets it from several directions. One of his partners holds him accountable, at his request, because he knows he performs better that way. The same coaching meetings everyone else has apply to him. Outside the firm, his Entrepreneurs' Organization forum holds him to his commitments. He also meets a mentor in person every quarter and sends him regular updates on what he has been doing and how the firm is performing.
He sets lofty goals on purpose, because he would rather stretch than feel complacent. Reading is part of it too, 20 to 25 books a year.
This matters for how the team sees it. Part of rolling out accountability, John says, is telling people that somebody is going to hold the leader accountable too. Otherwise it looks like everyone else answers for their work while the boss does whatever he wants.
How to create a weekly accountability rhythm
John's firm draws on the Rockefeller Habits. The structure is consistent.
Monday huddle. An eight minute huddle for the whole firm. They share wins from the last week, and employees recognize each other for living the company values.
Department meetings. Right after, 15 minute department meetings, including revenue by department and a weekly efficiency rating for each team.
Partner meetings. Two meetings a month for the management team, about an hour and a half each. One covers financials and performance. The other covers management, decisions and strategy.
Annual goals. Every July, every employee, John included, sets goals that align with the firm's goals.
Quarterly coaching. Each person meets their coach over lunch to review progress.
Reviews. Formal annual reviews, a self-evaluation, and upward feedback for managers from the people above, beside and below them.
They tried a daily huddle, but too many people work at client sites. Weekly suits their rhythm. The yearly goal is tracked on a large whiteboard wall, and the team celebrates when it hits its monthly targets.
What a coaching conversation looks like when someone falls short
In John's firm, the quarterly conversation is not about why you missed a goal. It is about how the organization, and the coach, can help you reach it. In John's words, it's not your falling short, we're falling short.
He gives an example. Everyone at the firm has a sales goal, even new staff, which he admits is funny for a CPA firm. It might be one small client a year. One person was nowhere near their target. John asked what he could do to help, and offered to make introductions. The person could not believe he would follow through.
He went back to his desk and sent probably 15 emails to his contacts, asking for bankers, attorneys and insurance people in that person's area. The responses were positive. Over the next month or so, that person had about nine lunches with new contacts, and it helped move the sales cycle forward.
John's point is that this only happened because the structure surfaced the gap early. Otherwise, everyone gets to the end of the year believing they did their job, and nobody knows why the firm missed.
How accountability helps you merge cultures after an acquisition
When John's firm acquires or merges with another firm, he is open from the start about how they operate. He says most new staff react very positively. Many have not had a coaching session or set goals in years, and they are excited to know how they are performing.
The conversation is honest in both directions. If someone wants to stay at their current level for the next 10 years, that is fine. They will discuss what that means for compensation.
Rolling it out right away has let the firm bring people into its culture quickly, instead of running two or three cultures side by side. John has seen what culture clash does. He has watched larger companies buy smaller ones, and a few years later none of the original people remain.
He also watches for drift. If people believe leadership is easing off, even a little, their actions change slightly. In a 35 person firm, three or four people heading in a slightly different direction makes a big difference a year later.
How to apply this in your business this week
Start with yourself, then build the rhythm.
Name one person who will hold you accountable this quarter, and tell your team who it is.
Introduce a short weekly huddle. Share last week's wins and recognize someone for living a company value.
Make your main number visible to everyone, and show progress against it.
Give every person one goal that connects to the company's goals, even a small one.
When someone falls behind, open with John's question. What can I do to help?
Notice where you have let yourself off the hook because it only seemed to affect you.
John's firm went from zero to 35 people in nine years. He says people like to know how they are performing, and they like being part of a team that is growing. Accountability, done this way, gives them both.
Related Insights
If you want to see where accountability and growth are breaking down in your company, an outside look can show where to start. The Growth Pattern Diagnostic
Wisdom Weekly. Get Wisdom Weekly, a short Sunday letter on leading what you have built. Subscribe to Wisdom Weekly
This conversation is part of the Culture Growth Hub, number 7 in its top 10. See every Growth Hub.
🎙️ Listen to Episode 24 of Paper Napkin Wisdom
▶ Spotify
