Why Customers Buy Emotion, Not Features: Darren Hickman on Selling Innovation
Updated: Oct 29
Darren Hickman wrote on his napkin that nearly all decisions are driven by emotions, and that you can use that in business. He learned it in advertising and marketing. Then he built a new technology for pools and hot tubs that uses sunlight to control bacteria, and he forgot it. He focused on the technical details. He tried to convince people the technology worked. People's eyes glazed over and they walked away. This is a trap for any founder who is proud of what they built and has a product that challenges a long held belief. The more innovative the product, the stronger the pull to explain it. Darren's fix was to flip the script. Start with what the customer wants, speak from their point of view, and let the technical proof come second.
Inspired by Paper Napkin Wisdom Episode 266 with Darren Hickman.
Why innovators fall into the feature trap
In advertising, Darren was taught a laddering exercise. You start with the product or service features. Then you move to the benefits, because people buy what something can do for them. A lot of companies stop there. The step most businesses now understand is the next one. People are buying what the product contributes to their life. That is the emotional benefit.
Darren knew all of this. He used to look for the emotional benefit on a day to day basis. And still, when it was his own product, he found himself focused on the science.
I notice how natural that is. When you are innovating, the product is everything. You are proud of the technical differentiation. You want to talk about it. And in his case the product challenged something every pool owner believes. Chlorine is the easiest, the cheapest, the most effective and the most widely accepted option. Everyone with a pool knows the sun kills chlorine. So the instinct is to argue, to prove, to put down the doubters. That instinct pulls you away from the customer.
How to tell your pitch is losing people
Darren did not get one big wake up call. He got hit in the head gradually. People's eyes glazed over. They stopped him in the middle of a long explanation and went back to something from the first minute. Some walked away. Others just stopped answering on the phone or online.
His read on it was simple. He was not grabbing people early enough. They were not excited enough to stay for the rest of what he wanted to say.
That is a useful signal for any owner. If customers keep pulling you back to the start, or the conversation goes quiet after your best explanation, the problem may be the order of the pitch, not the product.
How to flip the script to the customer's point of view
At one point Darren decided to stop talking about what the product does and how it does it. He led with the outcome instead. It reduces your need for chlorine by a minimum of 50% using only natural light. Then people said, tell me more.
From there he focused on what was valuable to them. You drop it in. One unit works for 12 months and emits no chemicals. And he translated each of those into what it means for the person. Easy, just like chlorine. Cheap, just like chlorine. And because it lasts much longer, it saves money and time.
He also built the emotion into the product itself. He knew he was challenging the chlorine market, so his first design had to be cool and aesthetically appealing. It has a fin that moves through the water like a shark, and his campaign plays off that fin. Later he released a plain tube that looks much more like a normal pool product. Consumers still overwhelmingly choose the fin. Because it's cool, and they want it in their pool.
There was one more emotional decision underneath it all. He did not ask people to change their routine. Most pool systems still need chlorine as a backup, so he positioned the product to work with what people already do. Asking them to switch everything out would have gained very little traction.
How to find customers who will give you honest feedback
Darren's first test group came from his past. He had sold organic skincare products to spas, hotels and resorts, and that world runs on hot tubs and pools. He asked those contacts to try it, give feedback and ask questions, so he could learn what people thought was really important.
The second phase was Facebook. He told his friends he was testing a prototype and offered a free product to anyone who wanted to try it. The free product was not the real draw. He was asking people to risk a pool and hot tub routine that already worked. They said yes because they wanted to help.
That is the part Darren says a lot of entrepreneurs forget. People want to help. You just have to ask. Some will do it simply because they were asked and they want to feel valuable and valued. I wonder how often we skip that and offer a prize instead. When the reward is the reason, you attract people who want to help themselves, and the feedback shows it.
The third phase was to roll the dice. Water is complicated. A dog jumps in, it rains hard, there is a big party. At some point you stop testing, get it into the market and collect feedback in public. Then you keep tweaking.
What humility protects you from when things go wrong
Darren went through four or five iterations of the tube and a lot of failures. The base technology held up. The substrate or the glue did not. Those failures were incredibly valuable, and he needed people who would not be offended when something went wrong.
Years of that made him humble. His view is that the founder on the podium, talking about how brilliant the product is, is hiding something. Launching a product means failures and long stretches when nothing much happens. If you believe in it and stick with it, you can become confident and humble at the same time.
Humility also matters when a customer reports a problem. I once sold a renewable fuel to fleets, and a fleet manager blamed it for a rise in flat tires. They had changed the tire adhesive at about the same time. That was a false negative, a failure that was never the product's. Darren sees the same thing in water. There are many things that could be wrong with a pool, from alkalinity to pH to calcium hardness. So he responds humbly and stays curious, knowing it may be something else entirely.
Pointing the finger is the opposite of empathy. Can you fake caring about your client? Darren says you can to an extent, but it reveals itself very quickly. It is better, easier and more stress free to just care.
How to apply this in your business this week
Take your main pitch and run Darren's laddering exercise on it.
Write down the features. Then the benefit of each one to the customer.
Next, for every benefit, write what it gives them emotionally. Easier, cheaper, more time, less worry.
Rewrite the first minute of your pitch so it opens with that outcome. Save the technical proof for when they ask for more.
Ask yourself what you would want to hear if you were seeing this product for the first time.
Make a short list of people who already trust you and ask them to try something and tell you what went wrong. Offer no prize.
When the next complaint arrives, go in curious before you go in defensive.
Notice where your own pride in the product is doing the talking. That is usually where the customer stopped listening.
Related Insights
Wisdom Weekly. Get Wisdom Weekly, a short Sunday letter on leading what you have built. Subscribe to Wisdom Weekly
This conversation is part of the Sales Growth Hub, number 9 in its top 10. See every Growth Hub.
🎙️ Listen to Episode 266 of Paper Napkin Wisdom
▶ Spotify
▶ YouTube




Comments